(1955). 108m. Tajo, Valletti, Noni, Bruscantini; Erede; Chorus & Orchestra of RAI. In Italian, no subititles. B&W (transferred from a kinescope)
DVD Region 0 (all regions) PCM audio
Detailed synopsis included.
PAL VHS ONLY
If you order a total of five or more qualifying DVDs, videos, CD sets or photos at the same time, you can receive a sixth item of your choice for FREE from this list. After you have placed the required five items in your shopping cart, you can select your free item from the list that will appear at the bottom of your shopping cart page.
Tajo makes you feel how fast Pasquale’s heart is beating when he meets “Sofronia.” His tones are soft in texture, warm and happy as he fantasizes about her (“Un foco insolito”). Notice how he blends his voice with the violins. His sound becomes resolute and a little gruff when he confronts Ernesto (“Prendo moglie”). When Norina slaps Pasquale, Tajo becomes affecting–but not to the point that the comedy is lost. From the slap onward, he is more whipped than angry. In bearing and facial expression, his Pasquale is suggestive of Walter Matthau. Tajo does mug.
Much of Pasquale’s music is patter singing or chatter. Thus the role traditionally has been played as a buffo caricato (exaggerated buffo), in the manner of Fernando Corena. Tajo plays it as a buffo nobile (noble buffo), accentuating the pathos over the comedy. The bottom line is his charisma does carry the performance.
As Ernesto, Valletti is heavily under the influence of his teacher Tito Schipa, who recorded the part. In certain passages, such as “Caro, caro,” in “Sogno soave e casto,” Valletti’s inflections sound Schipa-derived. He has the same wistful melancholy but not the charisma. His “Cercherò lontana terra” is understated, like Schipa’s, and he uses dynamics and tone color to contrast different sections of the aria. His top whitens in the manner of all Schipa pupils. (I myself stopped studying with Schipa in part to avoid this.) Del Monaco, Corelli and nearly all other tenors of the era invariably cover and darken their voices from the passaggio on up. Valletti in general does not. (When he does darken, it’s usually in the middle.) His capacious breath span enables him to join together some already lengthy phrases in “Com’è gentil.” He finds meaning in words others merely vocalize. His legato is beautiful–and is not at the expense of diction; his and Tajo’s is crystalline.
Since shortly after 1900 until recently, most singers have used mask placement (which is now being edged aside by mechanistic approaches). Noni’s is an extreme example, with the voice far forward in the face. Her top is a little wiry. She inflects words cannily. Hers is a mature Norina, yet she is expert at playing the innocent, making her transformation into the vixen the more telling.
Malatesta’s part has plenty of 16th notes, and Bruscantini articulates them without sounding choppy. His downbeats are expressive, with appoggiaturas accentuated, resolutions tapered so as to emphasize harmonic tension and deemphasize harmonic relaxation. (This is the opposite of “last syllableitis,” the prolongation or accentuation of the last syllable.) He and Tajo both have good trills and sing their patter with brio.
The ensembles include some repeats ordinarily cut in traditional performances. The production is straightforward. The camera captures facial detail that would be lost in the theater. —Stefan Zucker
Tully Potter, reviewing in International Opera Collector
“Opera enthusiasts are always nostalgic for singers of bygone ages; and although I would sooner have a good record than a bad film, there is a fascination just in being able to see how these marvels or monsters of the past moved. So Bel Canto Society is doing us a real favour in making so much old (and not so old) film and TV footage readily available.
“Don Pasquale is a gem. A 1955 Italian TV film with a cast which has rarely been equalled. Italo Tajo is an ideal Pasquale, firm of voice, histrionically hilarious but never going over the top; Sesto Bruscantini is a marvellous Malatesta, more human than this character is usually made; and these two great buffos seem to have more facial muscles between them than the rest of us put together. Their duet (without reprise) is a tour de force. Alda Noni has exactly the right mix of acid and humour for Norina and Cesare Valletti is a likeable, believable Ernesto. There has not been a better sung Don Pasquale; and both sound and vision are quite good in this edition. Alberto Erede conducts sensitively, opening some traditional cuts (the tenor caballetta is still out.)”
Alan Blyth, reviewing in Gramophone
“The RAI Pasquale of 1955 is almost as good as the two Verdis [#4 Otello, currently unavailable, and #551 Traviata], marred only by Italo Tajo’s overdone mugging in the title-part. Alda Noni, remembered affectionately by older opera-goers in the same part at London’s Cambridge Theatre in the late 1940s, remains a charming, minxish though now more buxom Norina. Sesto Bruscantini is a model of a Malatesta, Cesare Valletti even better as an Ernesto in the class of his teacher, Tito Schipa. Erede’s seasoned conducting and a resourceful staging makes this a delightful experience.”